Skip to main content

The 'Bhay' behind Nirbhaya's Documentary

Over the last week, 2 very graphic and disturbing videos were put out for mass consumption. One was a documentary on Nirbhaya and the second on the lynching of an alleged rapist in Nagaland. It is difficult to judge if one was the anti dote to the other but none the less its hard to me to agree with either ..

The key issue I have with the Nirbhaya's documentary is the follows

  • The documentary is called as 'India's Daughters' and attempts to make the world aware of the crimes against women. The documentary attempts to generalise that many women in India are often victims due to the attitude of men exemplified by the indicted rapist. Both these generalisations cannot be more wrong. Women in Indian history and society have always occupied a position far superior than in any western country. The feminine god - shakti is far more worshiped across the length and breadth of the country than any male god. We accept the women can be 'Messengers of God' Lets not forget the 2 greatest wars in our history ( Ramayana & Mahabharata) took place when the dignity of women was violated.
  • The rapist  DOES NOT represent the men of India or their attitude. Ask any women if their fathers or brothers think like the rapist on video and you will get your answer. Nirbhaya's incident shocked all Indians equally. 
  • Lastly the documentary reflects a typical western mindset - that its s white man's burden to make aware and reform a primitive backward civilisation like India. This narrative is similar to the other western narratives - we need to bring freedom to the primitive tribes of the middle east. Just like they maligned our nation and our religion using a few horrific instances such as Sati in the past, the same approach is being used there. Case in point is the use of images of Shiva in the Nirbhaya documentary...
  • The Nirbhaya documentary reminds me of an article in The Hindu which blamed Swami Vivekananda for the rapes in India. You can read that shocking article here 
We Indians are well aware of what is wrong with us and our society and moreover we have the self correcting means to reform ourselves The western scholars are better off looking at themselves 

Moving to Nagaland .... a mob of 10,000 raids a police station and gets hold of an alleged rapist. He is then stripped, paraded, castrated and killed. Videos are then posted online for mass consumption. 

The mob of Nagaland also does not represent the people of India. Lets not forget that unlike the western countries which assassinates terrorists, we gave a fair trial even to the perpetuators of 26/11. 

The vast population of India still retains a moral compass and we do not need education from outside. We have strength in our culture, our values and our religion to enable us to take corrective steps. 

The government of any nation is as bold as the society it governs. Ban on the videos is a reflection of the mood of the society - graphic content in both the videos from last week are not mandatory for the benefit of society and we can do well without them.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mauka Mauka for the Enemy Within

Two things unite a nation as diverse as India - culture and cricket. When any nation takes part in a world tournament and does well very in the initial stages, one would expect the people of that nation to back the team .... Over the past few weeks we had many intellectuals and prominent media houses hoping that India looses the semi finals against Australia ... It started with noted sociologist Ashis Nandy .... According to Nandy, India is suffering from too much national pride and winning the world cup will make it worse... This was followed by a national poll by a leading print magazine Outlook which asked .. "Should India win the World Cup ? "  You can take the survey here Outlook not only echoed Nandy's sentiments but went on to add that "winning the world cup might just make India's macho and hyper masculine nationalism more intense. Over the last few months, there seems to have been an effort to make a pluralistic India into a homogeniz...
Post a Comment
Read more

BJP Karyakarta has Won

The earliest memory I have of a BJP karyakarta was of my mother''s colleague and friend called as Rajani aunty . Rajni aunty and her family were dedicated, committed karyakartas of the RSS, Jan Sangh and then the BJP.  Their commitment was so complete that they made every contribution they could - tan, man and dhan. Even in the 1980's when the BJP was a very young party, Rajani aunty and her family stood like a steady rock. When Vajpayee lost in the 1984 election, there were tears in her eyes. Rajani aunty used to work as a professor at the Sophia college in Mumbai. Once she asked a rather innocent question in the GK paper - "Who is the founder of the RSS ? ". The secular Catholic management took a very hard view and she was forced to quit her job. For 2 years she did not have a job but never once regretted her commitment to the ideology. Through her trials , she always stood by the Sangh. Her family for generations and decades stood by the Sangh no matte...
Post a Comment
Read more

Why Vyapam will be Opposition's Vietnam ?

Opposition parties such as Congress, JDU, AAP  etc have been crying murder over the so called Vyapam scam in Madhya Pradesh. Lets first understand this 'Vyapam scam' .. What is Vyapam Scam ? Vyapam is a local board in Madhya Pradesh that conducts competitive exams. The current scam is about 326 students who got impersonators to take exams in their place. After clearing the exams, they got preferential job allotments. Scam has 2 parts first is impersonation and second is non merit based job allotments ...  Issue #1 - Impersonation ... Impersonation in examination is not limited to Madhya Pradesh ... its a national and an international issue ...Just Google ' Examination Impersonation' and see the results ...  Example - In Bihar 1000 fake candidates were found impersonating during exams a couple of months ago .. you can read the story here There is no state in India where impersonation does not happen. It is estimated that in any competitive exam , 20...
Post a Comment
Read more